Published in P.E.N. News 2003
From Mandalay Hill at dusk, the largest lit-up
building you see below you is Mandalay Correction Facility.
Then the legendary Lion Palace of Burma's nineteenth-century
kings, destroyed in World War II and brutally restored,
with forced labour, by the current régime. Mandalay has
no parks: people come up here to escape the sweltering
town.
"When the junta first took power,
they cut down all the trees around, for surveillance," said
my friends, "and the climate changed. Now they're
growing them back; you get a jail sentence for cutting
down a tree."
I was in Myanmar (the name
imposed by the anti-colonial, back-to-roots ideology of
General Ne Win's 1962 dictatorship) to do poetry readings
and workshops, and meet Burmese poets. The few tourists
I saw were mostly French. What tourists see is a beautiful,
obscenely poor country. There are a thousand kyats to the dollar, which is also
a teacher's weekly wage. Everyone smiles, everyone is slender,
men dandle babies lovingly, women walk safely alone.
"Should I tell people
to come here?" I asked. I was there in May, just before
the monsoon. Aung San Suu Kyi, leader of the Democracy
party, had just been released from house arrest, the country
was warily hoping for "good times" round the
corner. But good times have a long way to come.
"No way," I was
told. "Let the junta know tourism is waiting to happen,
the moment they change their policy on human rights. As
it is, tourists wouldn't see the truth."
I had with me the names of
ten imprisoned poets. One, aged fifty-seven, has been sentenced
until 2021 on a charge of "distributing information
regarding repression to international press agencies and
Western diplomats". Two others are reportedly in solitary
confinement, tortured; one vomiting
blood. Their crimes are "spreading information injurious
to the state", "spreading false news knowing
it to be untrue", "collaborating with terrorists". I
learned nothing of them, but did hear two others had been
freed.
Incessant
power cuts are another illustration of the truth the tourists
wouldn't see. People I talked to used
to get eight hours of electricity in seventy two hours.
Now they get eight in twenty four. You have to memorize
the rota in advance. If there's any international news
the state wants to stifle, there's a power cut at TV News
time, terminated for the football. (Not that many people
have TVs.) In tourist hotels the air conditioning just
registers a blib as the hotel switches to generator.
What tourists do see are "The
People's Desires". These things are everywhere: walls,
newspapers, and books: "Oppose those relying
on external elements, acting as stooges, holding negative
views; oppose those trying to jeopardize stability of the
State and progress of the Nation; oppose foreign nations
intefering in internal affairs of the State; crush all
internal and external destructive elements as the common
enemy". Writers have to pay to print this
stuff on the front paper of their own books.
The Burmese love laughing,
but the reality behind the 1984-type rhetoric is no joke. In 1989 a comedian spent six months
in prison for a light joke about a hat; in 1996 he was
back again with a seven year sentence for another - described
as "using words liable to
threaten public order and State security". This wooden
paranoia is a stark contrast to the impassioned
intelligence of Suu Kyi's father Aung San, the man who
freed Burma from the British. While studying History, Politics
and English in Rangoon University, he organized the first
student strikes in 1920. There is a monument to him and
his colleagues at the Shwedagon Pagoda. Thanks to him,
Burma was the first country to get Independence from Britain,
in 1948. But he was assassinated before it happened: in
1947, along with other statesmen and leaders of ethnic
minorities: who happen - this is one of the state's problems
- to inhabit the areas where most of the country's legendary
mineral (and drug) resources lie. Relations with them still
vex the "Union of Myanmar". Aung San foresaw
this. "We must work", he said in 1947, "for
rehabilitation. Comprehensive co-ordinated plans may take
weeks: those of you planning holidays should postpone them.
It is a matter of extreme emergency to restore the national
economy without delay."
Fifty-five years on, the urgency
is far more extreme, in education most of all. The beautiful
University campus in Rangoon - red-arcaded brick, green
tropical fronds and the odd cobra (Burma has some of the
most poisonous snakes in the world) - is abandoned except
by a few professors, because the junta has shunted undergraduates
to campusses outside the cities, whose main purpose is
to control students rather than teach them. In the Forties,
Burma had widespread literacy, Rangoon was the place in S. E. Asia (Bangkok was nowhere),
and everyone spoke beautiful English. After the 1962 coup,
Ne Win banned English as a medium of instruction. He reinstated
it when his daughter failed entrance to a British medical
school in 1979, but by then the damage was done. The population
had lost this linguistic open sesame, theirs by birthright
(at least the British Empire gave them that, in return
for the teak forests it gobbled up): the key to global
communication. Now the young are desperate to get it back.
Generals' children patronize
the International School. In state schools, you pay for
entry, text books, uniforms. Many people cannot afford
any of this, so many children go unschooled. The really
free schools are run by altruistic monks, or informally - I
watched one, in the country outside Mandalay - in hedgerows.
Child labour is common. In
Mandalay, in pre monsoon heat of a hundred degrees, I watched
the goldbeaters: two shifts of three twelve-year-old boys,
pounding gold into thin leaf in a non-stop rhythm like
oars on a Hollywood slave ship. In an inner room, little
girls of eight swelteringly packaged the crumbly leaf into
ten-kyat packets, sold to anyone who wants
to gain merit by layering a little gold onto a Buddha.
In Buddhism, you are your actions. In this deeply religious
country, you gain merit in your future life by deeds you
do in this one. The traditional way to do it is to build
a new pagoda and plaster it with gold leaf. The generals
are constantly photographed opening pagodas. The 326 foot
high dome of the Shwedagon Pagoda in Yangon, too bright to look at except far off or in the rain, is covered
with gold renewed every year.
Education is where the British
Council matters. In Athens, say, the Council offers one
cultural note among many. In Myanmar, it is a lifeline,
appreciated by an extraordinary range of people. It teaches
the language of global investment and communications, as
well as culture, opens windows to everything the Burmese
are cut off from. Most people have no access to the internet
or email. You can be jailed for owning the wrong sort of
modem, though people hope this may change, now. Most people
don't have telephones anyway.
In the British Council in
Mandalay, everyone was dying for rain. By the time I got
to the poetry section of the British Council's library
in Rangoon, the rains had arrived and umbrellas were everywhere. The
place was a wheel of activity, smiles and books, offering
the intellectually starved a place to read the world. People
were reading everything from dictionaries to Bridget
Jones.
Censorship here is an industry
with its own large building. Every printed word is vetted.
You cannot write "blood" or "condom" (which
makes Health Education difficult); nor "he kissed
her on the lips".
"He said I had to put
'chin' instead", said a writer I talked to. "I
wanted to ask if that's where he kisses his wife but didn't
dare". Poem-shaped black splodges are a common sight
in magazines.
Borges said that censorship
was "the mother of metaphor". This junta has
not read Borges but knows this truth fine. What it doesn't
know is where the metaphors lurk. So if you write "Blossom
falls to the ground" it is inked out: you may mean
students killed in a riot.
My workshops were the most alive and challenging discussions
on poetry I've ever had. Argument, mainly through interpreters,
raged. Does the power to analyze poetry makes you a
better poet? I furiously argued not, and had with me
spare proofs of my book, 52 Ways of Looking at a Poem, poised to come out the moment I got
back. "The poets in here who can't - or any rate
don't - analyze poems, are just as good as the ones
who can," I said. "They are all part of the
same enterprise - but they are all different." Shyly,
I left the proofs with them.
Under the
thrumming monsoon rain, in a] bar closed to host our
discussions, the roomful of poets cheered when either
side scored a point. They had never met all together
before, to hear each other read and argue. Private societies
are suspect. Informers, like the mother of metaphor,
are everywhere. These poets had not been able to glean
an overview of any other community of poets: books are
desperately hard to come by and anyway most people cannot
afford them. The catalyst was the British Council and
a foreign poet.
My last day I had tea with Suu Kyi in
Yangon, and told her the poets of Mandalay were panting
to see her. The last time she tried to leave Yamgon the
military stopped
her by uncoupling the carriage of her train. Now, joke
the ever-buoyant citizens of Mandalay, they'll let her
come but arrest everyone else, so she'll have nobody to
talk to.
"I will come to Mandalay",
she said; and I saw in the papers later that she did. When
I told the poets I
had met The Lady they said instantly, as poets would in
any country, "Did you show her our poems?" "No." I
said. "Sorry. But I did tell her that when Burma is
a democracy it'll have some really wonderful poets."
In Burmese pagodas - around
the base of the Shwedagon, for instance, among the sphinxes,
leogryphs, elephants, lions, cobras, and demons - are little
side-shrines to the nats, indigenous spirits who
co-operate with Buddhism. In front of many are large egg-shaped
stones, lying free on the marble paving. You pray, "If
my wish will be granted, may this stone be light as a feather",
and lift the stone.
These stones are a Burmese speciality. They are wishing
stones. But Suu Kyi is back in confinement, today.